top of page
Search

Natural Wine? We’d Rather Know How It Was Made

Oct 23
6 min read

Nature can make grapes ferment. Making wine, however, is something else.

That is probably where our problem with the expression “natural wine” begins.

Not with producers who choose spontaneous fermentations.Not with those who use very little sulphur dioxide.Not with those who avoid filtration or fining.And not with those who work organically or biodynamically.

The problem is the word itself: natural.

Because it sounds simple, reassuring and immediate, while in reality it tells us very little about what happened before that wine reached the glass.


La selezione dei vini di Seresin di La Bidule

Wine does not exist by removing people from the equation

Wine is the result of thousands of years of knowledge, trial and error, observation and technique.

Grapes can ferment spontaneously. But deliberately turning them into a healthy, stable wine capable of expressing a place and a vintage requires knowledge and skill.

Even the OIV definition of terroir includes not only soil, climate, topography and biodiversity, but also the viticultural practices applied by people.

Human intervention, therefore, is not necessarily what prevents a wine from expressing its origin. It can be what makes that expression possible.

This is why we are not convinced by the equation:

less intervention = more authentic wine.

Sometimes it can be true.

But not automatically.


“Natural” compared with what?

There is also a very practical problem.

In the European Union, “natural wine” is not a legally defined wine category with one shared regulatory standard in the way other certifications are.

And since 2026, the issue has become even more relevant.

With Italian Legislative Decree 30/2026, implementing EU Directive 2024/825 against greenwashing, generic environmental claims in commercial communication are subject to much stricter rules.

It is no longer enough to imply that a product is “green”, “environmentally friendly” or somehow better for the environment.

Claims need to be specific and verifiable.

This does not simply mean that the word “natural” is always forbidden.

It does mean, however, that when it is used to suggest environmental superiority, it cannot remain an empty word into which anything can be placed.

And this is exactly where, for us, the issue becomes interesting.

We would rather know what a producer actually does than know how that producer has decided to define themselves.

Organic farming. Biodynamics. Spontaneous fermentation. Resistant grape varieties. No fining. Filtration or no filtration. Reduced sulphur dioxide. Soil management. Integrated pest management.

Those are pieces of information.

“Natural”, by itself, is a label.


A fault does not become a virtue simply by changing its name

There is another aspect that matters even more to us, because it concerns what eventually ends up in the glass.

Around so-called natural wines, there is sometimes an idea that certain sensory deviations are part of the style, almost as if they were proof of authenticity.

We do not agree.

We can debate taste endlessly.

We may love or dislike skin-contact wines.

We may prefer a cloudy wine to a perfectly clear one.

We may enjoy a deliberately oxidative style.

We may even love a wine that smells reductive when first opened and then changes completely in the glass.

But excessive volatile acidity, microbial spoilage, unwanted sulphur compounds or unintended oxidation do not become expressions of terroir simply because they appear in a wine described as natural.

The OIV itself explicitly includes volatile acidity, microbial contamination, unwanted sulphur compounds and oxidation among recognised wine faults in sensory evaluation.

Of course, concentration matters.

A trace of volatile acidity does not automatically make a wine faulty.

A deliberately oxidative winemaking style is not the same as a wine that has oxidised unintentionally.

But a production philosophy cannot become an excuse.


Less intervention requires more expertise, not less

And this is where we reach a paradox.

We are absolutely in favour of producers who manage to make great wines with very little intervention.

But precisely because they choose not to use certain tools, they need an even deeper understanding of fermentation, microbiology, oxygen, temperature and wine stability.

Non-intervention is not the absence of control.

Manincor is a beautiful example.

The estate works according to biodynamic principles, has been certified for years and uses spontaneous fermentations with the yeasts naturally present on the grapes.

And even in its own description of its cellar work, Manincor speaks about the experience required to follow and guide these processes step by step.

Seresin, in New Zealand, also works organically and biodynamically and, for some wines, goes as far as spontaneous fermentation, no fining, no filtration and no added sulphur dioxide.

We appreciate producers like these precisely because they prove something important:

it is possible to work in an extremely low-intervention way without turning faults into a stylistic signature.


La selezione dei vini di Manincor di La Bidule

The tools of oenology are not something to be ashamed of

At the same time, we do not share the opposite idea either: that using selected yeasts, filtration, fining, temperature control or sulphur dioxide somehow turns a wine into an artificial or “chemical” product.

They are tools.

They can be used well, badly, excessively or unnecessarily.

They can affect the final result, which is precisely why they should be used with judgement.

But using an authorised winemaking tool does not mean adulterating a wine.

And above all, it does not mean that everything that is not described as “natural” is some kind of laboratory-made liquid.

Our preference remains simple:

the less correction a wine needs because the grapes and the work behind them are better, the better.

But we do not turn technical tools into a moral issue.


And what about sulphur dioxide?

Here too, we prefer to avoid ideological camps.

Sulphur dioxide is an extremely useful tool for protecting wine against oxidation and unwanted microbial development.

We greatly appreciate producers who manage to use less of it without reducing the quality, cleanliness or stability of the wine.

But “less sulphites” does not automatically mean “healthier”.

Sulphites can be problematic for sensitive individuals, and that is a real issue.

However, turning this specific sensitivity into the universal explanation for the headache after an evening in which too much alcohol was consumed is something else entirely.

A hangover is multifactorial: alcohol contributes to dehydration, disrupts sleep, irritates the gastrointestinal system and triggers other physiological responses.

Sulphites may cause headaches in sensitive individuals, but they are not the general explanation for post-alcohol discomfort.

And above all, a wine described as natural still contains alcohol.

From a health perspective, ethanol remains the fundamental factor.

The World Health Organization reminds us that all alcoholic beverages carry alcohol-related risks and that, in relation to cancer risk, no completely risk-free level of alcohol consumption has been identified.

So no:

“natural” does not mean “healthy”.


If we want to talk about the environment, we should look especially at the vineyard

This is where our position changes significantly.

If a producer can genuinely reduce treatments, tractor passes, fuel use, water consumption and the overall environmental impact of viticulture, that is something we believe deserves attention.

This is one reason why we find PIWI varieties — grape varieties resistant to the main fungal diseases — so interesting.

A study published in 2026 compared PIWI and traditional grape varieties in the same experimental vineyard.

Under the conditions studied, the resistant varieties required two fungicide treatments instead of 12–14 and showed environmental impacts up to three times lower in some of the categories assessed.

And here we also have an example very close to home.

Nove Lune, in Cenate Sopra, in the province of Bergamo, is a winery we have also chosen for our selection at La Bidule.

It works exclusively with resistant grape varieties and was created with the specific aim of cultivating grapes that require very few antifungal treatments.

PIWI Lombardia was also founded at the estate.

For us, this is a very concrete kind of revolution.

Not because there is an attractive word to place on a label.

But because it genuinely changes what happens in the vineyard.

La selezione dei vini di Nove Lune di La Bidule

Perhaps the real revolutionaries were already working quietly

This is also why we find it difficult to credit the natural wine movement with inventing environmental awareness in viticulture.

For decades, growers, agronomists, researchers and producers have been working to improve vineyard health, reduce treatments, experiment with resistant varieties and grow better grapes.

Many of them did so without creating a category around themselves.

Perhaps the real revolutionaries are precisely those who spent years working quietly without ever feeling the need to call themselves revolutionary.


So how do we choose a wine?

We are not particularly interested in whether it belongs to the “natural” or “conventional” camp.

We look for something else.

We look for the ability to interpret terroir.

We look for uniqueness and originality.

We look for a producer capable of expressing a vintage without using it as an excuse for a poorly made wine.

We look for technical precision.

And above all, we look for drinkability.

Because we can discuss philosophy, yeasts, sulphur dioxide, filtration, maceration and certifications for as long as we like.

But eventually someone has to pour that wine into a glass and drink it.

And for us, a wine should above all be enjoyable to drink.

Otherwise, why would we drink it?

Perhaps, then, we should stop dividing the world into “natural” and “non-natural” wines.

There are wines that move us and wines that move us less.

There are technically clean wines and faulty wines.

There are producers who do extraordinary work in the vineyard and then manage to carry that work into the glass with equal precision.

Those are the producers we would rather value.

Not the word they have chosen to define themselves.

The choices they made to reach the glass.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page